Why can't the Bible Change?



            I have heard the argument that the Bible or our understanding of it should be "allowed" to change. After all, science does! Cultures do! We gain more understanding, and we shift with that new knowledge.

            This perspective is all well and good for mere mortals whose understanding of the earth and their place in it is circumscribed. The problem is, Christians want to claim that their god is all-knowing and all-loving. Some claim that this god is outside of space and time and presumably knows how events will play out. How can this god change? Why would this god change?

            There is a reason science changes. New scientific discoveries resolve some questions, but usually they also open new doors with new problems to solve. Sometimes, scientists look at new math or develop new hypotheses but the tools to test the equations or ideas still need to be developed. I have heard some Christians marvel that "science" has changed its mind on the age of the earth, chuckling as if science was acting in a fit of whimsy, as it woke up one morning and said, "Hey, I think I'll say the earth is millions of years old from now on!" The reality is we began to be able to see further and further. We developed new telescopes that could see beyond our solar system, then beyond our galaxy. We developed tools to peer into the universe, and as our tools developed, the age of the universe had to be updated.

            The tl;dr of science is we change because we get new information. We are not all-knowing, omnipresent beings occupying a timeless space.

            Religion, on the other hand, claims to be based off of some supernatural being. Christianity claims its god is omniscient and omnipresent, not bound by our mortal limitations on space and time. One would presume that this being would have access to permanent truth, that an immoral action is always such, and that explanations about the formation of the universe would be consistent across time.

            Really, the knowledge and morality contained in the Bible appears to reflect the understanding that people of that time period had. Reading that we shouldn't kill each other or steal from each other is not so breathtakingly ahead of its time. It is a staple of all times and cultures. If a transcendent, supernatural being were really behind these revelations, I think the Bible would have more astounding verses than it does. But more than that, if it really was the revelation of the the tri-omni god, it would not have to shift, bend and warp to remain relevant.

(This is the third post on arguments about the Bible. You can see Part I on the problems of divine inspiration and human error and Part II on the Bible needing to change because ancient humans weren't ready for the kind of knowledge we enjoy today.)

A few random pleasures for this afternoon:
-going into an air-conditioned place on a hot day
-checking off items from the "to do" list
-feeling the buzz and excitement that is Friday

            

Comments

Popular Posts