Build that wall - of separation, Part I
For those of us who are secular-minded, the notion of
separation of church and state is not difficult. When government stays silent
on religion in its policies and upholds the rights of all citizens to hold
their beliefs in speeches, religion does not become coercion and means of
repression.
For certain groups of Christians, to the extent that they
are sincere of course, Yahweh seems to require omnipresence in our communal
life. Their "closely held beliefs" extend to political life and
policies that threaten other people's ability to act on their faith.
What is "freedom of religion" anyway? Are
Christians being "persecuted" for their beliefs? Well, that second
one is easy: not in the USA! But does freedom of religion mean you can treat
people however you want because of your beliefs? If you held a religion that
allowed human sacrifice, should that be allowed? I think we can all agree that
the right to practice your religion stops at the point where it interferes with
other citizens' ability to live their lives. Actually, this particular
statement gives you the parameters of freedoms in general: freedom extends to
the end of your fist.
A discussion for another day is that our freedoms come with
responsibilities. It is easy to find discussions about what we have the right
to do, freedom, liberty and so on, and many of those people are quick to shirk
what they owe to others. But we need to recognize too that the boundaries of
our actions need to be negotiated and defined. Our actions do impact others,
and we need to measure and gauge to what effect: if, when and how we enact
legislation around our actions.
But to return to freedom of religion. There are some simple
questions to ask to determine if you are suffering persecution: Are you able to
attend the place of worship of your choice? Are you able to attend study
sessions and lectures for the religion of your choice? Do you know people who
share your belief and are able to discuss your religion openly with them and
others? If you answered yes, you are not being persecuted.
What doesn't constitute persecution is that you live in a
place with laws you disagree with, people say they don't share your belief,
people call you close-minded for your belief. Criticism and lack of agreement
are not persecution.
In our culture, religion permeates all of life, so
Christians might not even recognize how present their beliefs are. It is a
trite stereotype to make a character in a show or film Christian to demonstrate how humble and good they are. It's a shortcut and lazy strategy so you don't have
to build the character's personality. Even a simple comment like the character
prays is enough to establish this is a
good person. Politicians feel they have to say they are praying for victims
of various tragedies, and if they don't there are plenty of Christian
conservatives across the media ready to criticize them for their arrogance and
godless communist tendencies.
But there are so many examples of how Christianity pervades
all aspects of our culture. When I drive anywhere, I see Christian billboards.
Some of them merely have Bible quotes; some are about a local church; some
denounce sin. There are channels on tv dedicated to Christian broadcasting.
Wherever I drive, churches take up acres of land. People on my Facebook and
Twitter talk about how #blessed they are because their spouse brought them
coffee in bed.
I'm not bringing these issues up to say they shouldn't exist
or that we need to remove them. I am merely saying that there are plenty of appropriate
places for our religious speech in the private realm. It doesn't need to be in every nook and cranny, and
it is illegal and a violation of the constitution for our government to express
a preference for one belief over another.
Comments
Post a Comment